Technical Annual Status Report (Stage 2) for the CLRTAP Inventory Review: Synthesis and Assessment Country report

RecalculationsKCATime seriesTrend graphsAdd Comments


TIME SERIES

Party: BE      Submission year: 2025

The aim of this test is to identify instances of dips, jumps, and sudden changes in time series data reported by countries. The analysis was limited to data provided in NFR02, NFR09, NFR14 and NFR19 reporting format. Only data reported for at least three years were considered. Years where only NFR02 or NFR09 sectors were available have been converted to NFR14/NFR19. Only the converted sectors are in the time series analysis.

The table below shows data, where outliers in the time series were identified based on the following methodology: Reported time series data were log 10-transformed prior to analysis to reduce intra-series variability and improve general time series linearity. A linear regression was subsequently applied to the log-transformed values for each time series.

An individual value within the time series was identified as a dip/jump if the respective residual value (regression forecast value - reported value) is more than 2 standard deviations from the mean of all residuals in the time series. Only time series where the flagged data value contributed a significant fraction (>3%) of the national total for the given year are included in this dataset for expert review.

Time series where sigma grow largely (i.e. more than 20% of the time series mean value) because of extreme variation in the emission data are also flagged. Zero values indicate small numbers rounded to zero.

The test was performed for the following time series (if data was available):
Main pollutants: 1990 – 2023
HMs and POPs: 1990 - 2023
PMs: 2000 - 2023

If there is a number and a notation key reported, the difference is the number.

Color Key

 

Indicates a dip in the time series data

 

Indicates a jump in the time series data

 

Indicates time series data with large sigma


MAIN (Unit = Mg)
1990199119921993199419951996199719981999200020012002200320042005200620072008200920102011201220132014201520162017201820192020202120222023
NOx2C15261534046056500577650585169555251584800545542084918468351875056570649314548336151745010433841834242417844584210399339863455475145904008
NMVOCNTCOMPL(NECD)36043935517234856334114232359631449030706829430028550327053924490823885222373321296120199716169119176018248217479116284416167115067514765314403113709413622313206213036612827012748192452907138270082810
SOx1A2c18171238142247121264128489652494550764388374837825501320725412728254320792011174111538591362969288305394408377405421335336294221
SOx1B2c24706085882472252582697201228621494152516551863144917861696118530422707209114361791110716281485152718021563202810211824864
SOx2B10a17390157271316711194936389778464913392868043763368447024438340314570413754084145230832003329246624542344246226052791258525302273219120071497
SOx2C1106281097894418965929485847668620762806825805861306645601766186369567859235714384150075360580760265421469856095210631858703543399639734569
SOx2C7c7269684544784890464737013894260427273176360936973302327336983241281134613100122419232125241324723029288827292292209219871609139212981355
CO1A3ai(ii)1305137013341442153618082355331858607422968011291140121861018507133351708615174239583256240232449353538722271253042955344118403608612516337587443685296447793
CO2A2196821369512113124311405112282106611237312717148843410633651392983668517462365813360517195256051920836796267531516170365266731547148312591303128610539321077748

PM (Unit = Mg)
200020012002200320042005200620072008200920102011201220132014201520162017201820192020202120222023
PM2.51A1a124874410467248346365057136055225554393292942583152541842241756366102182
PM2.51A3bvi117112081232126213171279131113491356134913241314127012471280133913521327133113161125119012431301
PM2.51A3bvi(fu)107811011121113011541161118512141175116911661175118011631182119612131236124812661022103711641252
PM2.51A3bvii544560570583610594609629631624621614591583598626631620621613537599611632
PM2.51A3bvii(fu)504514522526536539551567547541548550549543552558566577581590487511564602
PM2.52A5b559537518503512524546488367306970391396395411376391389477485492535469437
PM2.52C1625755645015508651484375457834613738776135810999406218001048962602453523479495380301
PM2.55E625626629632635638642647652659668672732750580722695831722951920695783790
PM101A3bvi223323022345240225022427248625532570255925072488240523602422253425572506251224812109220523102423
PM101A3bvi(fu)205320952131214821922203224622982227221822072224223622002237226222942334235423871916192921702337
PM101A3bvii10081037105610801129110011291165116911561150113810941080110811591169114911511136995110911311170
PM101A3bvii(fu)9349529679749939991021105010121001101510191017100610231034104710681076109390394610441114
PM102A5b559553725176502551165238545648813671305997043906396139524111376039143885477248514917534846914366
PM102C1890579916986719272066122623045664933970163113001186773102013151205808638696636663549411
PM105E625626629632635638642647652659669673732750580722695831722951920695783790
TSP1A3bvi288329743032310732403146322533173336331832573231312330663148329433253263327332352764291930493193
TSP1A3bvi(fu)265427092758278128392856291429862890287528692889290328592907294029833039306731132510254528563075
TSP1A3bvii201520742112216122582199225723302338231223012276218821602216231723382297230222721990221822622340
TSP1A3bvii(fu)186819031935194819851998204121002024200220292037203520132045206820952135215321851805189220892228
TSP2A5b186691793517288167901709117499182281630212249102063244813037132221319313726125491306612970159281618616408178481565514569
TSP2L56531111   0090775678713362055212116352023195719402385
BC1A1c280253198919493916832143344496756512
BC1A2e616265445960455036344235324539373538343225805034
BC1A3bvi273282288296309301310320321318314311300295304318321316318315272295306319
BC1A3bvi(fu)252258263265271274280288278275277278279275280284288294298303247255285306

HM (Unit = g)
1990199119921993199419951996199719981999200020012002200320042005200620072008200920102011201220132014201520162017201820192020202120222023
Pb1A1a3753660733330914433920513365562322527494698926796811589836930309551209547146135312353631069938107536911958481318335745833557041596711867012457231527253440693271140252763213931311343236568268889287285234390171689205224200245
Pb1A2a1428361165296915811261535560147307411391741133349111942311644109936461106695817479119990371620886182282671661498482707381766080005512668481229790113240310337941016613951373960727217122154377148124143725141297144130143317
Pb1A3bi107589791102879943102544115887121488125746377767329731485166659072465893926591785524746761460768443788044409437402615556615522924939845372390737843706359835483650382139463964415043493534411144534703
Pb1A3bi(fu)946808889170470684852040739982986617535961295923579602495491892553404617481072593908297371155334835263407638322158150315449354172238537335133173295333032923346344236423825399442003302355541234629
Pb1A3bvi(fu)5870212615424062698796228528658751066636566785848700689072739087542267761674377603207880955793037880767328091604822905183790358147872814816280485708123910817285780285948156233824177483430768460934850721386033926798719669027275748958171778
Pb1A4bi2182719253643023284682278200150601314931291712001144461512825241193754104145811239029429379912919477639488359503549105631091973123870310369258166338891601022310776721829005840159785656765662728681663562807225742587760174
Pb2A246130943399241921641942143975544739343155443059445405046382244333042596244115741882017245511593038525944134516564710676923468839503769648876821012314435588811267615547366637952956769382930524932
Pb2A3320236727307873151561161209216677680183756861782846817539230153043112685781051731118168914644691621794189689513947621030716266050824403611740437499110376199335460363681399847341577368829290107270194270889270273352182340735240553
Pb2C139313352381169113429272427491282262542882945093762849829931929795041959771635884665652154463506554158032529607136235067251416357523870564098217253989673147451362205968415253778163233711340294511653959166876471577921114966943291351247892712504141184949221786632072879
Pb2C7c3117333427585598374237154126640220286000335448783108210930531483173304082071757910611914101286619989858865220585727219589761426028346693362709924224917325067242470129192189920550972095898282421520810812010131230681621349122680402201389016897561674296
Pb2G1664243166404516634911662769166322116643371766209183048716392551784993147038410739497562016854422814714480287129041079476147441118129791846159183269215537971297342968174867086751153696123621455680567618092418545486711484088
Pb2I   1102 1088749 180491 12171341154704112100085625445703580702928619432310220194655316644131917000815000246000131850105000945001800047390473904739047390473904739055390
Pb5C1a1582848514971566100255703171311692692871251585058444353971732311265122500481391162002151258001537581601637856148431061376716488779139712832782875150720663758166810703917
Cd1A1a124952911464801393225345718344185414980773886282344272245107282150078964421514991610711981971271528457310516524840011465513099313630710947284273567007112883300939651262741029131144591013859085895238
Cd1A1b1100011000110001100011000109881300514008325081746610984109396677100348886529899091144747927193346737777417393284137324393753542138726442564474438285382853823543880
Cd1A2a5222953132539465040856587532825188344863536714596645721441173949332969375003583266873310288803254262744235381130491339262325918110169103924294729022597240326932745
Cd1A2c338303615433276306252918629333175771483119440167406678766938588385827361346623776009556124591395897563701693785954153369596215891994422750543586644832753783574635296355676
Cd1A3bvi(fu)26021272992783727750292972966230215311613237633590339363459935164354113608936204368603761036518364553612936441366453602936612370083749138076383333881430880307003465637358
Cd1B2aiv     19519529239333022009622767423356323308423258341552592293646944875379493458023053407563912244909442274039140774365454413035441410761955721991
Cd2A14346743801454804110341395409933764937775371923668733411267112424829952582182211028332138031145750234431727091971143713515525697528157143891790413412698861470516091
Cd2A33533831881329763289433881543680947804338981356595846637567679628804039991314401213557112327014876014381811564410784068512714486640078697718747499557491510514019342046475584794942463
Cd2C163604558798353636046615346750550347162762870768559413261548191779061497082866683625011561836784979044317676578843843043535595284266932039191924821462054746655068592485166837412357370994519415450298551
Cd2C7c2283108229363631085513592027173000023580951186965194526245780758094229006638655023211524789819625925956411628411084655320524624903956986656735326263296931376809458410744305825757683343973048227118
Cd5C1a806527780426572911951727888427175136165326199926109347080539021409670412173169236186853098189266214840593671124143081784528331091271371
CdNATIONALTOTAL6025227583711666118645447082386573049004504033285419456322644102226200258889123013902384435248797530059592390220251659322929592647088176280119723281692657148600014762441260508164117925799311351827120094711877441098336117709210546351114455
CdNTCOMPL(NECD)6021855583481466087215443695386222648969144029589419083322606642222986258539222973742380291248312330002812386246251231022884012641104175684419671081688071148305714734761257292163654825755201348984119832511861371095101117259310523371113140
CdNTCOMPLIANCE6021855583481466087215443695386222648969144029589419083322606642222986258539222973742380291248312330002812386246251231022884012641104175684419671081688071148305714734761257292163654825755201348984119832511861371095101117259310523371113140
Hg1A1a245068522999742479839108760196794211007929363991082147851507445055557220503720134716012931599842072173291051082332083576292205762604081374699937514661111271515362510772814068898592103083926287804279675119082
Hg1A1c376406333204292671252117237779238379238142213270184976178275179742182465152762151948163104158500777505923817576170001700016240250002500012000         
Hg1A2a51486033545551015199508051174232814394472414186157282565125713251162068516053214455504937021464604449333080353763009728099276135581570156615565573555855703
Hg1A2c37463593054178439335365393220322415187941892612297697966867762653608386422765267643496168065751639876820071824704726566667082692886255459098631275734362043641676013256343
Hg1A2gviii1517114711132031160210790102286165312182134589571163301610513412147811350713182130621293115858161651576119610175431769519557170291720715767188071586817082176192161123781
Hg1A3bi30011303483197531998323773249832417315163200331761313213147331197316733161829879298643013330538309253037029943290392849329085302743070830256307423116024996283112983830888
Hg1A3bi(fu)26562275542765527678277962754627582274092775627946275832736127009268592685326873265202658926306266472671726749269822655526811272422808128855293533011623220245312778130319
Hg1B2aiv     546624857223644232031239311239296239819292414737124296304592467321323121802938029160347183408732306283222564032147250393117470359478
Hg2A1326189325276335153331462343022348874326788334388333969331441310300290861367045410714563506236981228889392677441841537714227821251292248466237799286475186500367366121546201086201538250800209446339832134709
Hg2A34658837371419534321744328498664754248065516894683150480564235429355243491352812131984343943111428540280403009148379360933277529480354395104288142146627666360724261932220
Hg2B10a981447983008102455310653951722050584225570792892189398047498396684855498362346135306046345300271042291753216986218632217518200994212834188326297829273577152786149962146845336871039850427751793408
Hg2C1258409241005212419182194260778245771205817350701387938979528553300419043743609578418603332673116600356160101318673951837423956652502521504971082411949549721211843869514444699822598982114527010633995876
Hg2C7c28702390475987163232 1150230310 142225001423271426261391921593811776941120971165891100361228295363055871575496030354041272363046386231622526538711621888928863557604957037
Hg5C1a10703119808547557771831699995128818838690234062532524307771830720509111331088011015191810412321651953418141576804401150252260273468649174265
Hg5C1bi535318362666138206210124262866139878145320126301000900180100010001700250070302431102512396317792035661570374690006640196929700500700200
HgNATIONALTOTAL6059745579495357172523703141412739133185133262633373359426825023044102320108528233633867919367112035985942216551199257331859163646376176238217203081449724128826713723181357817106613312871699260771248840891657922161920605976098760434
HgNTCOMPL(NECD)6055090579161457126283698164412242433134713257528372886726777953040082319675728184923862871366516835919412211936198754931805753639595175567717144831444661128498813691911354181106107812824619231861246080889879918510913756972366758534
HgNTCOMPLIANCE6055090579161457126283698164412242433134713257528372886726777953040082319675728184923862871366516835919412211936198754931805753639595175567717144831444661128498813691911354181106107812824619231861246080889879918510913756972366758534

POP (Unit = mg)
1990199119921993199419951996199719981999200020012002200320042005200620072008200920102011201220132014201520162017201820192020202120222023
DIOX1A2a175158157135153158153133149146148120133125119101147235381288021271107126272325268197214174124122222120
DIOX5C1bi789278927892845112507829199788316161115181706194011113343   579133909796646741327116715
DIOX5E6126615261756205622662456253627562856298631363286357638864156448649065366590664366976762737375565857724469738058717886438842782778697949
HCB2A186719908765150937591092909409622780927195085793709040050900143088643209341600892987083719807826170773441083683408708740865067083692407597110711115060427406000880250192028511409363305478902932098012543404909601498104859103953804061530
HCB2C1939326684704367176606754717661343667038646593819866202117207003716197677026288105351873829485730517620996636404065134676286405674409885675622002021830704377196792765432602572250612331841332755336777206753787333225577223803206496
HCB5C1biii21025521025521025516982012782514857214457814628664922570927954476014551026200269063     1204626961167732204744217626235334228190221027251541259255247969294842280421271111
HCBNATIONALTOTAL40140401393211613863959558098615863930281149251499269044782394096562248064114595921050591207018882072996719781503197882861924192019994599202287611908150110693786105197679422043119441189798222765568672418646202503631926623285896019227862165908193761217957075408956
HCBNTCOMPL(NECD)40140242393210293863936058098381863927551149248469269013482393779562244794114568121050268207015152072958819781056197876961924147719994128202282611908077710693073105191809421997619440942798203265566672418372202480831926500285886719227502165835193751117956755408948
HCBNTCOMPLIANCE40140242393210293863936058098381863927551149248469269013482393779562244794114568121050268207015152072958819781056197876961924147719994128202282611908077710693073105191809421997619440942798203265566672418372202480831926500285886719227502165835193751117956755408948
PCB1A1a19652203101994420298206152069822411199181948817915176512018623422274162117121182468686626277962565224268242371391923128142781650228821211441242241218625237688227281210834281451
PCB1A4bi3223405375814933681143268553195789219251042203400186396215851231457844116170012385461008102907684764976789335758253708153736545876665501979476463418155481625409266331261225443205430187709148288129058145581124028107500
PCB2A132607703204630331273032500703401970336061031573803279540324236031689203395340320207030645502905830286546030640503175340316822030747202716980707992304537619037514902674400806074013015203312850915690281505028282501821960555476019856501526270
PCB2A3190000131500194320198290225810193000188830194700214920131400971001260001470002350002050002050002470002530002150002020001040002500002060008000100070005000536006800019000056000134000168940129300
PCB2C1903288807712806069647310642188606992167075961940649878807086281083859590754837408200332084777540875718808374788079444140645339607519771058957020593861101049958022812490104271004816380166982026213601021190124936012355409898608871809018501534500595420764700
PCB2K2110817921099679210660402104805820987792209379942091583320847943208139872076557320606050204759492030844920263207202144492018427220113343200993462008392820492197216067552087790023852588321116832325509237616080467822544646803413809096106738165027986888516291816162727
PCBNATIONALTOTAL118956463106177642982723099260333696910506102773271918476059742260111004082810126775710756871611012144911244563710841978910388216089229623999341058371890084135738352923881161719397774192633341342372780303469221440734450525587724932160119310244153909738752572895769137218323751907
PCBNTCOMPL(NECD)118956419106177609982722569260328096910443102773203918475349742252911004075510126769510756864511012136811244555510841969310388203789229531999340088371879784135591352922441161718207774183433341292372779913469217440734394525587274932157619310225153909658752558895767037218263751905
PCBNTCOMPLIANCE118956419106177609982722569260328096910443102773203918475349742252911004075510126769510756864511012136811244555510841969310388203789229531999340088371879784135591352922441161718207774183433341292372779913469217440734394525587274932157619310225153909658752558895767037218263751905