Technical Annual Status Report (Stage I) of CLRTAP and NECD Inventory Review for Romania

Generated by CEIP: 3 rd June 2014

This status report was prepared by the EMEP Centre on Emission Inventories and Projections (CEIP) and European Topic Centre on Air and Climate Change (ETC/ACC). The Status Report provides information based on the initial checks of the CLRTAP and NECD inventories submitted in accordance with the reporting requirements of the UNECE Convention on Long-Range Transboundary Air Pollution (CLRTAP) and its protocols, and for EU Member States the Directive 2001/81/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council on national emission ceilings for certain atmospheric pollutants (NECD).


Review Process

The technical review of national inventories involves the checking and assessment of national data submissions with a view to improving the quality of emission data and associated information.

The annual review process is carried out in three stages in accordance with the review guidelines developed by the Task Force on Emission Inventories and Projections (TFEIP) and as agreed upon by EMEP and the Executive Body of CLRTAP in 2007: Methods and procedures for the technical review of air pollutant emission inventories reported under the Convention and its protocols ( ECE/EB.AIR/GE.1/2007/16 ).

Stage 1: An initial check of submissions for timeliness and completeness;

Stage 2: A synthesis and assessment of all national submissions with respect to consistency and comparability of data with recommendations for data quality improvement;

Stage 3: In-depth reviews of selected inventories, by pollutant, country or sector, as in the workplan agreed by the Executive Body.

If you have any comments concerning the results of the tests in this report, please contact the EMEP Centre on Emission Inventories and Projections (CEIP) by email at emep.emissions@umweltbundesamt.at
within two weeks of your receiving this Status Report.


STAGE I REVIEW TESTS

This Stage 1 Status Report documents assesses the timeliness, completeness, and format of the submitted national inventories. It presents results of these initial automated tests to countries and supports the subsequent Stage II and Stage III review process. Stage I tests are:

1a Timeliness

1b Format of submission

1c Completeness per sector for 2012 emissions

1d Completeness per pollutant of your data in the WebDab database

Data included in tests:

Emissions reported under the Convention on LRTAP.

Emissions reported under the NECD Directive to the European Commission and European Environment Agency.


1a TIMELINESS

Date of submission of NECD : 20.12.2013 , received within deadline 31.12.2013

Date of submission of CLRTAP : 14.2.2014 , received within deadline 15.02.2014 (Resubmission: 2.6.2014)

Informative Inventory Report (IIR): Received


1b FORMAT OF SUBMISSION

Parties are invited to check consistency of the format via RepDab (http://www.ceip.at/check-your-inventory-repdab) before the submission of their inventory to the UNECE secretariat, the EMEP Centre on Emission Inventories and Projections (CEIP) and/or the European Commission/European Environment Agency. This section indicates whether the data submitted were in the Nomenclature for Reporting (NFR or Flat-file) and the files were formatted as requested in the Guidelines for Estimating and Reporting Emission data.

NECD inventory submitted in format: NFR09 (Version 2009-1) for the years 2011 to 2012

CLRTAP inventory submitted in format: NFR09 (Version 2009-1) for the years 1989 and 2005 to 2012; Projections for 2015, 2020 and 2030


1c COMPLETENESS PER SECTOR (YEAR 2012)

NE in the tables below shows for which sectors you have reported 'Not Estimated' in the 2012 emission data (also the associated sectors are coloured). Sectors where you have reported only notation keys are listed as well, but without colouring. There are only priority pollutants included in this analysis. At the end of the table you can see a statistic of how many sectors are listed and the number of reported 'NE' notation keys per pollutant. For NECD you can see the sector completeness not only for 2012, but also for 2011 emission data.


CLRTAP (Completeness per sector for 2012):

SectorNOxNMVOCSOxNH3PM2.5PM10TSPCOPbCdHgDIOXPAHHCBHCHPCB
                 
1 A 1 b   NE         NANANA
1 A 1 c             NENANA
1 A 2 a   NE          NA 
1 A 2 b NE NENENENE NENENENENENENANA
1 A 2 cIEIEIEIEIEIEIEIEIEIEIEIEIEIEIEIE
1 A 2 dIEIEIEIEIEIEIEIEIEIEIEIEIEIEIEIE
1 A 2 eIEIEIEIEIEIEIEIEIEIEIEIEIEIEIEIE
1 A 2 f iiIEIEIEIEIEIEIEIEIEIEIEIEIEIEIEIE
1 A 3 a i (i)NENENENENENENENENENENENENENENANE
1 A 3 a ii (i)NENENENENENENENENENENENENENENANE
1 A 3 b i          NE  NENANE
1 A 3 b ii          NE  NENANE
1 A 3 b iii          NE  NENANE
1 A 3 b iv          NE  NENANE
1 A 3 b vNA NANANANANANANANANANENANENANE
1 A 3 b viNANANANA  NENA  NENANENENANE
1 A 3 b viiNANANANANENENENANENENENANENENANE
1 A 3 c  NE     NE NENE NANANA
1 A 3 d i (ii)NENENENENENENENENENENENENENENANE
1 A 3 d ii   NE       NANENANANA
1 A 3 eNANANANANANANANANANANANANANANANA
1 A 4 a i   NE          NA 
1 A 4 a iiIEIEIEIEIEIEIEIEIEIEIEIEIEIEIEIE
1 A 4 b iiIEIEIEIEIEIEIEIEIEIEIEIEIEIEIEIE
1 A 4 c i   NE          NA 
1 A 4 c ii  NE     NANENANANANANANA
1 A 4 c iii   NE        NE NANA
1 A 5 aNENENENENENENENENENENENENENENANE
1 A 5 bNENENENENENENENENENENENENENENANE
1 B 1 aNA NENANE NENANANANANANANANANA
1 B 1 bNE NE    NE   NA NANANA
1 B 1 cNENENENENANANANANANANANANANANANA
1 B 2 a iNA NENANANANANANANANANENANANANA
1 B 2 a ivNA NENANANANANANANANANENANANANA
1 B 2 a vNA NENANANANANANANANANENANANANA
1 B 2 bNA NENANANANANANANANANENANANANA
1 B 2 c  NENENENENE NENENENANENANANA
1 B 3NENENENENANANANANANANANENANANANA
2 A 1NENENENA   NENENENENENENENANA
2 A 2NENENENA   NENENENENANANANANA
2 A 3NANANANANANANANANANANANANANANANA
2 A 4NANANA NENE  NANANANANANANANA
2 A 5NE NANANENE  NENENENENENENANA
2 A 6NE NENA   NENANANANENENENANA
2 A 7 aNANANANANANANANANANANANANANANANA
2 A 7 bNANANANANANANANANANANANANANANANA
2 A 7 cNANANANANANANANANANANANANANANANA
2 A 7 dNANANANANANANANANANANANANANANANA
2 B 1 NENE NENANA NANANANANANANANA
2 B 2 NANANENENANANANANANANANANANANA
2 B 3NENANANANANANANANANANANANANANANA
2 B 4NENENENANANANANANANANANANANANANA
2 B 5 aNE NE    NENENENENENENENENE
2 B 5 bNAIENAIEIEIEIENANANANANANANANANA
2 C 1   NE        NE NA 
2 C 2NENENENENENE NENENENENENENANANA
2 C 3 NE NE    NENENENE NENANA
2 C 5 aNENENENE   NE    NENENA 
2 C 5 bNENENENE   NE    NENENA 
2 C 5 cNANANANANANANANANANANANANANANANA
2 C 5 dNENENENE   NE    NENENA 
2 C 5 eNANANANANANANANANANANANANANANANA
2 C 5 fNANANANANANANANANANANANANANANANA
2 D 1   NE    NANANANANENENANA
2 D 2NA NANANENENENANANANANANANANANA
2 D 3NENENENENENE NENANANANANANANANA
2 ENENENENENANANANANANANANANANANANA
2 FNANANANANANANANANANANANANANANANA
2 GNANANANANANANANANANANANANANANANA
3 A 3NANENANANANANANANANANANANANANANA
3 B 1NA NANANENANANANANANANANANANANA
3 B 2NA NANANENANANANANANANANANANANA
3 CNE NENENENE NENE NENENENENENE
3 D 1NA NANANENANANANANANANANANANANA
3 D 2NA NANANENANANANANANANANANANANA
3 D 3NE NENENENENENENENENENE NENENE
4 B 1 a  NE   NANANANANANANANANANA
4 B 1 b  NE   NANANANANANANANANANA
4 B 13NENENANENANANANANANANANANANANANA
4 B 2NENENA NANANANANANANANANANANANA
4 B 6 NENA   NANANANANANANANANANA
4 B 7IEIENAIEIEIENANANANANANANANANANA
4 B 9 cNEIENAIENANANANANANANANANANANANA
4 B 9 dNEIENAIENANANANANANANANANANANANA
4 D 1 aNENENE NENENANANANANANANANANANA
4 D 2 aNANENENENENENANANANANANANANANANA
4 D 2 bNANANANANANANANANANANANANANANANA
4 D 2 cNANANANANANANANANANANANANANANANA
4 FNANENANENANANANANANANANANANANANA
4 GNANENANENANANANANANANANANANENANA
6 ANA NANENENENENANANANENANANANANA
6 BNA NA NENENENANENENENANANANANA
6 C a   NENENE      NE NA 
6 C b   NE        NE NANA
6 C cNONONONONONONONONONONONONONONONO
6 C dNENENENENENENENENENENENENENENANA
6 C eNE NE    NENENENE NENENANA
6 DNANENE NENENENANENENENENENENENE
7 ANENENENENANANANANANANANANANANANA
                 
1 A 3NANANANANANANANANANANANANANANANA
1 A 3 a i (ii)NENENENENANANANANANANANANANANANA
1 A 3 a ii (ii)NENENENENANANANANANANANANANANANA
1 A 3 d i (i)NENENENENANANANANANANANANANANANA
11 ANONONONONANANANANANANANANANANANA
11 BNENENENENANANANANANANANANANANANA
11 CNENENENENANANANANANANANANANANANA
7 BNONONONONANANANANANANANANANANANA
                 
107 of 117 NFR09 Sectors listed                
Count of 'NE' sectors per pollutant3635434129221619212027232729416


NECD (Completeness per sector for 2012 and 2011):

2012

SectorNOxNMVOCSOxNH3
     
1 A 1 b   NE
1 A 2 a   NE
1 A 2 b NE NE
1 A 2 cIEIEIEIE
1 A 2 dIEIEIEIE
1 A 2 eIEIEIEIE
1 A 2 f iiIEIEIEIE
1 A 3 a i (i)NENENENE
1 A 3 a ii (i)NENENENE
1 A 3 b viNANANANA
1 A 3 b viiNANANANA
1 A 3 c  NE 
1 A 3 d i (ii)NENENENE
1 A 3 d ii   NE
1 A 3 eNANANANA
1 A 4 a i   NE
1 A 4 a iiIEIEIEIE
1 A 4 b iiIEIEIEIE
1 A 4 c i   NE
1 A 4 c ii  NE 
1 A 4 c iii   NE
1 A 5 aNENENENE
1 A 5 bNENENENE
1 B 1 aNA NENA
1 B 1 bNE NE 
1 B 1 cNENENENE
1 B 2 a iNA NENA
1 B 2 a ivNA NENA
1 B 2 a vNA NENA
1 B 2 c  NENE
1 B 3NENENENE
2 A 1NENENENA
2 A 2NENENENA
2 A 3NANANANA
2 A 5NE NANA
2 A 6NE NENA
2 A 7 aNANANANA
2 A 7 bNANANANA
2 A 7 cNANANANA
2 A 7 dNANANANA
2 B 1 NENE 
2 B 2 NANANE
2 B 3NENANANA
2 B 4NENENENA
2 B 5 aNE NE 
2 B 5 bNAIENAIE
2 C 2NENENENE
2 C 3 NE NE
2 C 5 aNENENENE
2 C 5 bNENENENE
2 C 5 cNANANANA
2 C 5 dNENENENE
2 C 5 eNANANANA
2 C 5 fNANANANA
2 D 1   NE
2 D 3NENENENE
2 ENENENENE
2 FNANANANA
2 GNANANANA
3 A 3NANENANA
3 CNE NENE
3 D 3NE NENE
4 B 1 a  NE 
4 B 1 b  NE 
4 B 13NENENENE
4 B 2NENENE 
4 B 3  NE 
4 B 4  NE 
4 B 6 NENE 
4 B 7IENENEIE
4 B 8  NE 
4 B 9 a  NE 
4 B 9 b  NE 
4 B 9 cNEIENEIE
4 B 9 dNEIENEIE
4 D 1 aNE NE 
4 D 2 aNANANANA
4 D 2 bNANANANA
4 D 2 cNANANANA
4 FNANENANE
4 GNANENANE
6 ANA NANE
6 C a   NE
6 C b   NE
6 C cNONONONO
6 C dNANANANA
6 C eNE NE 
6 DNANENE 
7 ANENENENE
     
1 A 3NANANANA
1 A 3 a i (ii)NENENENE
1 A 3 a ii (ii)NENENENE
1 A 3 d i (i)NENENENE
11 ANONONONO
11 BNENENENE
11 CNENENENE
7 BNONONONO
     
97 of 117 NFR09 Sectors listed    
Count of 'NE' sectors per pollutant35335138

2011

SectorNOxNMVOCSOxNH3
     
1 A 1 b   NE
1 A 2 a   NE
1 A 2 b NE NE
1 A 2 cIEIEIEIE
1 A 2 dIEIEIEIE
1 A 2 eIEIEIEIE
1 A 2 f iiIEIEIEIE
1 A 3 a i (i)NENENENE
1 A 3 a ii (i)NENENENE
1 A 3 b viNANANANA
1 A 3 b viiNANANANA
1 A 3 c  NE 
1 A 3 d i (ii)NENENENE
1 A 3 d ii   NE
1 A 3 eNANANANA
1 A 4 a i   NE
1 A 4 a iiIEIEIEIE
1 A 4 b iiIEIEIEIE
1 A 4 c i   NE
1 A 4 c ii  NE 
1 A 4 c iii   NE
1 A 5 aNENENENE
1 A 5 bNENENENE
1 B 1 aNA NENA
1 B 1 bNE NE 
1 B 1 cNENENENE
1 B 2 a iNA NENA
1 B 2 a ivNA NENA
1 B 2 a vNA NENA
1 B 2 c  NENE
1 B 3NENENENE
2 A 1NENENENA
2 A 2NENENENA
2 A 3NANANANA
2 A 5NE NANA
2 A 6NE NENA
2 A 7 aNANANANA
2 A 7 bNANANANA
2 A 7 cNANANANA
2 A 7 dNANANANA
2 B 1 NENE 
2 B 2 NANANE
2 B 3NENANANA
2 B 4NENENENA
2 B 5 aNE NE 
2 B 5 bNAIENAIE
2 C 2NENENENE
2 C 3 NE NE
2 C 5 aNENENENE
2 C 5 bNENENENE
2 C 5 cNANANANA
2 C 5 dNENENENE
2 C 5 eNANANANA
2 C 5 fNANANANA
2 D 1   NE
2 D 3NENENENE
2 ENENENENE
2 FNANANANA
2 GNANANANA
3 A 3NANENANA
3 CNE NENE
3 D 3NE NENE
4 B 1 a  NE 
4 B 1 b  NE 
4 B 13NENENENE
4 B 2NENENE 
4 B 3  NE 
4 B 4  NE 
4 B 6 NANE 
4 B 7IENENEIE
4 B 8  NE 
4 B 9 a  NE 
4 B 9 b  NE 
4 B 9 cNEIENEIE
4 B 9 dNEIENEIE
4 D 1 aNE NE 
4 D 2 aNANANANA
4 D 2 bNANANANA
4 D 2 cNANANANA
4 FNANENANE
4 GNANENANE
6 ANA NANE
6 C a   NE
6 C b   NE
6 C cNONONONO
6 C dNANANANA
6 C eNE NE 
6 DNANENE 
7 ANENENENE
     
1 A 3NANANANA
1 A 3 a i (ii)NENENENE
1 A 3 a ii (ii)NENENENE
1 A 3 d i (i)NENENENE
11 ANONONONO
11 BNENENENE
11 CNENENENE
7 BNONONONO
     
97 of 117 NFR09 Sectors listed    
Count of 'NE' sectors per pollutant35325138


1d COMPLETENESS PER POLLUTANT (entire time series)

The completeness of your data in the WebDab database of priority pollutants has been evaluated on the basis of the criteria outlined in 2009 Guidelines for Estimating and Reporting Emission Data under CLRTAP (ECE/EB.AIR/97):

All numbers in table are as a percentage of the total number of reporting template cells per component and time series. Flagging occurs when the number of cells containing a value or a notation key is less than 80% of the total number of cells, if there are more than 10% zeroes reported, if 'Not Estimated' is reported in cells and/or if the number of values reported is less than 10%. The completeness of CLRTAP NFR Sectors is divided in three sections: 1980 to 1989, 1990 to 1999 and 2000 to 2012.


CLRTAP (Completeness of National Totals from 1980 to 2012 including NFR and SNAP):

Component% Value% 0% NO% NE% NA% IE% C% NR% All
NOx100.00.00.00.00.00.00.00.0100.0
NMVOC100.00.00.00.00.00.00.00.0100.0
SOx100.00.00.00.00.00.00.00.0100.0
NH3100.00.00.00.00.00.00.00.0100.0
PM2.561.50.00.038.50.00.00.00.0100.0
PM1061.50.00.038.50.00.00.00.0100.0
TSP61.50.00.038.50.00.00.00.0100.0
CO100.00.00.00.00.00.00.00.0100.0
Pb34.80.00.065.20.00.00.00.0100.0
Cd34.80.00.065.20.00.00.00.0100.0
Hg34.80.00.065.20.00.00.00.0100.0
DIOX43.50.00.056.50.00.00.00.0100.0
PAH43.50.00.056.50.00.00.00.0100.0
HCB43.50.00.056.50.00.00.00.0100.0
HCH0.00.00.065.234.80.00.00.0100.0
PCB43.50.00.056.50.00.00.00.0100.0

"Value" the cell contains a number > 0.005;
"0" the cell contains 0 or a number < 0.005;
"NO", "NE", "NA", "IE", "C" and "NR" are notation keys as defined in Reporting Guidelines and NFR;
In certain cases the total percentage value may not be exactly the sum of the other columns because of rounding differences


CLRTAP (Completeness of NFR Sectors from 1980 to 1989 without National Totals):

Component% Value% 0% NO% NE% NA% IE% C% NR% All
NOx0.00.00.00.033.00.00.00.033.0
NMVOC0.00.00.00.021.00.00.00.021.0
SOx0.00.00.00.029.00.00.00.029.0
NH30.00.00.00.023.00.00.00.023.0
CO0.00.00.00.036.00.00.00.036.0

"Value" the cell contains a number > 0.005;
"0" the cell contains 0 or a number < 0.005;
"NO", "NE", "NA", "IE", "C" and "NR" are notation keys as defined in Reporting Guidelines and NFR;
In certain cases the total percentage value may not be exactly the sum of the other columns because of rounding differences


CLRTAP (Completeness of NFR Sectors from 1990 to 1999 without National Totals):

Component% Value% 0% NO% NE% NA% IE% C% NR% All
NOx0.00.00.00.033.00.00.00.033.0
NMVOC0.00.00.00.021.00.00.00.021.0
SOx0.00.00.00.029.00.00.00.029.0
NH30.00.00.00.023.00.00.00.023.0
CO0.00.00.00.036.00.00.00.036.0
Pb0.00.00.00.047.00.00.00.047.0
Cd0.00.00.00.056.00.00.00.056.0
Hg0.00.00.00.048.00.00.00.048.0
DIOX0.00.00.00.033.00.00.00.033.0
PAH0.00.00.00.039.00.00.00.039.0
HCB0.00.00.00.080.00.00.00.080.0
HCH0.00.00.00.090.00.00.00.090.0
PCB0.00.00.00.089.00.00.00.089.0

"Value" the cell contains a number > 0.005;
"0" the cell contains 0 or a number < 0.005;
"NO", "NE", "NA", "IE", "C" and "NR" are notation keys as defined in Reporting Guidelines and NFR;
In certain cases the total percentage value may not be exactly the sum of the other columns because of rounding differences


CLRTAP (Completeness of NFR Sectors from 2000 to 2012 without National Totals):

Component% Value% 0% NO% NE% NA% IE% C% NR% All
NOx16.80.81.818.532.93.60.00.074.2
NMVOC25.51.01.817.818.05.50.00.069.6
SOx9.51.11.822.135.23.10.00.072.7
NH313.60.91.820.928.05.50.00.070.4
PM2.517.81.00.815.528.14.20.00.067.3
PM1018.51.10.811.830.94.20.00.067.3
TSP17.21.00.88.835.83.70.00.067.3
CO13.00.80.810.447.13.10.00.075.4
Pb10.70.90.811.252.93.10.00.079.6
Cd11.80.80.810.755.83.10.00.083.1
Hg8.30.80.814.352.83.10.00.080.0
DIOX10.91.20.815.247.53.70.00.078.9
PAH8.21.30.816.649.93.80.00.080.8
HCB4.81.20.815.568.23.10.00.093.4
HCH0.00.00.62.490.13.10.00.096.2
PCB5.70.70.68.977.82.90.00.096.2

"Value" the cell contains a number > 0.005;
"0" the cell contains 0 or a number < 0.005;
"NO", "NE", "NA", "IE", "C" and "NR" are notation keys as defined in Reporting Guidelines and NFR;
In certain cases the total percentage value may not be exactly the sum of the other columns because of rounding differences



-------------

NECD (Completeness of National Totals from 2001 to 2012 including NFR and SNAP):

Component% Value% 0% NO% NE% NA% IE% C% NR% All
NOx66.70.00.00.00.00.00.00.066.7
NMVOC66.70.00.00.00.00.00.00.066.7
SOx66.70.00.00.00.00.00.00.066.7
NH366.70.00.00.00.00.00.00.066.7

"Value" the cell contains a number > 0.005;
"0" the cell contains 0 or a number < 0.005;
"NO", "NE", "NA", "IE", "C" and "NR" are notation keys as defined in Reporting Guidelines and NFR;
In certain cases the total percentage value may not be exactly the sum of the other columns because of rounding differences


NECD (Completeness of NFR Sectors from 2001 to 2012 without National Totals):

Component% Value% 0% NO% NE% NA% IE% C% NR% All
NOx18.20.81.912.130.33.60.00.066.7
NMVOC27.41.21.914.117.74.60.00.066.7
SOx10.21.71.914.535.03.30.00.066.7
NH314.71.51.913.529.85.70.00.066.6

"Value" the cell contains a number > 0.005;
"0" the cell contains 0 or a number < 0.005;
"NO", "NE", "NA", "IE", "C" and "NR" are notation keys as defined in Reporting Guidelines and NFR;
In certain cases the total percentage value may not be exactly the sum of the other columns because of rounding differences